Dissolving the divide – The new social contract for South African agriculture

Author: Sara-Lea van Eeden

The divide in South African agriculture has hardened into something deeper than disagreement. Trust has broken down, almost irreparably.

Almost. This is about what it would take to dissolve that divide from the inside. The argument can be put in one sentence. The opposite of division is not unity. It is shared conduct.

FMD is the virus that revealed the wound

Foot-and-mouth disease is the most visible example of this fractured trust. It exposes everything: who reports disease and who hides it, who moves animals responsibly and who does not, who can be trusted to keep a system intact under pressure and who cannot. Every decision around it, reporting, movement, biosecurity, vaccination and communication, now sits inside suspicion. The disease is doing what diseases do. The trust failure around it is doing something far more serious.

But it would be a mistake to treat this as a single commodity problem. The technical issue changes from sector to sector. The trust issue does not.

Agriculture cannot rebuild trust commodity by commodity, because risk does not respect commodity boundaries. A failure of trust in one sector erodes confidence in others, because farmers, vets, traders, processors and officials all move across them.

In every case, the underlying question is the same.

How do we prove to one another that we are acting in a way that protects livelihoods?

This is the question every part of the sector is asking. Every commodity group, every region, every type of producer faces some version of it. And right now, no one has a credible answer that crosses commodities, regions or scale.

Before any answer is possible, it helps to see how deep the fragmentation actually runs.

The many cuts that divide

Agriculture, like the whole of South Africa, is fragmented in almost every direction it is possible to be fragmented in. Historically, culturally, economically and institutionally.

The farmers’ associations and co-operatives that once shaped commercial farming, the traditional authorities and communal arrangements that have long held smallholder agriculture together, and the trust between farmers and government, are all under their own pressures, and have all thinned in their own ways.

None of these structures were ever perfect. But they were the layer of social fabric that allowed people inside each community to know each other well enough to hold one another accountable. Much of that fabric has thinned, and very little has replaced it across the lines that South African agriculture most needs to bridge.

The result is that farmers are more disconnected from one another, more disconnected from value-chain partners, and more disconnected from institutions than perhaps at any point in recent memory. Across communities that need to find ways to operate together, the connecting tissue is thinner than the work requires.

And it is precisely in that disconnection that divisive voices, of every kind, find their easiest audience.

The divisive few

There is a useful idea from Malcolm Gladwell’s The Tipping Point. He called it the Law of the Few. In any social setting, a small number of well-connected, emotionally clear, socially fluent people can shape the direction of a wider group. Anyone watching agricultural conversation on social media has seen it. It does not take many voices to set a tone. It takes a few who are loud, certain, emotionally vivid and socially well placed.

The problem in South African agriculture is not that the sector is full of divisive people. The problem is that the divisive few are visible, while the reasonable majority are silent. Divisive voices offer three things that are very hard to compete with in a fragile environment: belonging, certainty, and someone to blame. Belonging gives people a place. Certainty gives them rest. Blame gives them direction. None of these things are helpful. But all of them feel like relief.

The antidote to this should then surely be to build another loud group on the other side? But the answer is not another power centre or the new spokespeople for everyone else. The task at hand is to create the conditions in which reasonable people can find one another again.

That work begins with what those conditions are made of.

From compliance to honour

Compliance is what you do because you have been told to. Compliance is enforced from outside. Compliance produces minimum standards.

The shift is from compliance to something older and stronger, something deeply familiar across many, if not all, South African cultures: honour.

Honour is what you do because of who you are and who you stand with. Honour is held from within. Honour produces standards worth being known for.

But honour, and honour cultures, are two different things, and South Africa is currently watching the difference play out. Honour is a personal quality, held from within, expressed through conduct. Honour culture is a structural social norm, where reputation must be aggressively defended, often through public confrontation or violence. The first builds trust. The second consumes it.

What if we could draw on the dignity of honour without the volatility of honour culture? What if we could build something that uses the constructive instincts already present in South African cultures, while creating the structures that make those instincts safe to act on?

The cultural raw material for this kind of trust is already present in South Africa. The work is not to invent a new ethic. It is to give an existing ethic a structure that holds it steady.

Honour is made visible through proof and responsibility.

But honour does not survive in any environment. It needs the right one.

Image Credit: Lizel Snyman Photography, NAMPO/ALFA

The power of context, and the overstory

The other idea worth borrowing from Gladwell is the Power of Context. Behaviour changes when the environment changes. People do not act only on their values. They act on the cues around them. 

In his later book, Revenge of the Tipping Point (2024), Gladwell sharpened this idea with a stronger concept: the overstory. The overstory is the governing narrative of an environment, the quiet shared sense of how things are and how people in this place behave. 

The overstory of South African agriculture is a hyper concentration of the general South African overstory, amplified by the outbreak of foot-and-mouth disease. 

Within overstories, messages are shaped before they are heard.

Information about a disease outbreak lands inside a story about who is to blame. A standard lands inside a story about who is being controlled by whom. A research finding lands inside a story about whose interests it serves. 

Until the overstory changes, no message will travel cleanly.

Information does not travel well in a low-trust environment. You can produce facts, accurate science, good policy and clear communication, and watch them all dissolve in an environment that is structurally hostile to them. 

You cannot communicate your way out of a trust problem.

That means the work is not, in the first instance, to fix the message. The work is to fix the environment that produces the message. You do not change an overstory by saying different things. You change it by building different things, structures that over time, produce a new overstory.

And those structures have to be designed for the sector as it actually is.

Different starting points, same game, verified by peers

South African agriculture has another issue. Not all farmers are operating at the same scale, with the same capital, infrastructure or market access. But if the standard is set for one, it excludes the other. And if it is lowered for everyone, it stops meaning anything.

The golf handicap principle offers a third way that makes it possible for someone with ten head of cattle on communal land and someone with a thousand head in the Free State to both be visible inside the same system.

The golf handicap system was developed in Britain and Scotland in the late 1800s, when clubs needed a way for players of different skill levels to compete fairly against one another. Each player kept a record of their scores. Other players signed those scores off. From those records, a handicap was calculated, which became the number that allowed any two players, however unequal in skill, to share a fair round of golf. By the early 1900s the system had been formalised, and a version of it now governs amateur golf around the world.

It does two things at once.

The first is that it allows players of very different ability levels to share the same round, fairly. A scratch golfer and a high-handicap golfer can compete and the result still means something. Without the handicap, they cannot share the course. With it, they can.

This matters for the trust environment. The handicap principle answers the question of inequality without erasing difference. It says: you do not need to be the same to be in. You need to play honestly to your own line.

The second thing the handicap system does is hold the whole arrangement honest. A player submits a score, and another player signs off. The integrity of the game depends on the honesty of the people playing it. No one polices it from above. The system holds because peers hold it. It is decentralised. It depends on shared conduct rather than central enforcement. It survives because the participants understand that the value of the game depends on the integrity of those who play it. The standard is owned by the players, not imposed on them.

That is the principle agriculture needs. Not another regulator. Not another body issuing instructions from above. A way of proving conduct to one another that is calibrated to real conditions, owned by farmers themselves, witnessed by peers, and supported by industry infrastructure rather than enforced by it.

A system like this needs people willing to set the first standard.

From the divisive few to the reasonable few

The people best placed to start this are not the most famous voices in agriculture. They are not the loudest. They are the ones whose conduct has earned credibility over time. People who are quietly known, in their own districts and sectors, as farmers and role players who can be trusted.

The reasonable few are not influencers. They are standard-setters. Their job is not to become central. Their job is to seed a new behaviour pattern. They are trusted because of their conduct, not because of their title. The moment they start trying to become famous, the work fails. The moment they start performing, they become another version of the problem they were meant to address.

They are not trying to convert the whole sector. They are trying to make their conduct recognisable, then visible, then normal, until enough producers in a region or commodity group are doing things that way that others begin to join without being asked. The shift is not from minority to majority. It is from invisible to inevitable.

It looks less like a campaign and more like a slow change in what is considered normal. People begin to notice that certain producers do certain things. Others start to do them too, not because they were told to, but because that is what people like them are doing.

But conduct alone is not enough. Standard-setters need spaces in which standards can actually be set.

Trusted forums

If practical proof is one half of the answer, the other half is what might be called trusted forums. The phrase needs to be understood carefully, because it can sound softer than it is.

Trusted forums are not alignment meetings. They are not another industry forum where the same voices say similar things to the same audience. They are something more specific. Their purpose is to create a space where farmers and value-chain role players can disagree honestly, understand each other’s context, and define what responsible conduct looks like in real conditions.

The strongest description is this:

South African agriculture has many groups speaking about one another, but not enough structured spaces where they can think with one another.

The point of a trusted forum is not the meeting itself. The point is repeated contact around shared responsibility. That is how context changes behaviour. People do not begin to trust each other through a single conversation. They begin to trust each other through repeated contact, in a structure that protects honest disagreement and builds shared understanding over time.

There is also a quieter principle underneath this. You need a shared practical activity that gives people a reason to cooperate before they fully trust each other. Trust does not always begin with feeling. Sometimes it begins with doing something practical together, in a structure that is good enough to hold the relationship while the trust catches up.

Practical proof can become the first layer of social repair.

For these forums to be honest, they have to make room for what the standard alone cannot answer.

What survival forces people to do

There is a part of this conversation that is usually avoided, because it is uncomfortable. People sometimes make risky or harmful choices not because they are immoral, but because the system has left them choosing between survival and principle.

A farmer under financial pressure during movement restrictions. A producer who fears that reporting disease will destroy a business that supports an extended family. A trader trying to keep an income alive in a market that has already broken around them. A farmer who knows the right thing to do, and cannot afford to do it alone.

This does not excuse harmful conduct. It does not soften the standard. But it changes what the standard-setting conversation has to be honest about. A real trust environment must be safe enough to say: this is what the standard requires, and this is where the system makes that standard difficult to live by.

The principle:

Community is not only where people are praised for doing the right thing. Community is also where people can admit that survival is forcing them into choices that the system should not be asking them to make.

This is what makes a trusted forum morally serious rather than naive. It does not only ask: what is the right thing to do? It also asks: what makes the right thing difficult, and what must the community or the industry infrastructure carry, so that responsible conduct becomes possible? Without that second question, standards become judgement. With it, standards become a shared project.

The new social contract

Pulling these threads together, the shape of the new social contract becomes clearer.

The trust environment in South African agriculture is already being shaped. It is shaped by the loudest voices, the weakest structures, the fastest rumours, and the absence of better spaces. The question is not whether the environment is being shaped. It is whether responsible people will shape it openly, ethically, and in service of repair.

It is the deliberate work of designing conditions in which trust can become possible again. The same forces that produce harm also produce repair: the slow shaping of the overstory, the influence of a small number of voices over many, the conduct that becomes recognisable enough to invite others in. When these forces are unowned and hidden, they corrode. When they are visible, owned and held to a standard, they rebuild.

The opposite of division is not unity. It is shared conduct. People do not have to agree on history, politics, identity, race, scale or even policy before they begin to rebuild trust. They only need to agree on how responsible people behave when the industry is under pressure.

Shared conduct becomes possible when honour is held by people whose conduct has earned credibility. The reasonable few are not influencers. They are standard-setters. Honour, made visible through proof and responsibility, gives them something to be recognised for, and gives others something to recognise.

That recognition needs a structure that fits real conditions. The handicap principle is the way in. Different starting points, the same game, verified by peers. Not another regulator. Not another body issuing instructions from above. A way of proving conduct to one another that is calibrated to real conditions, owned by farmers themselves, witnessed by peers, and supported by industry infrastructure rather than enforced by it.

It also needs spaces where people can think with one another, not only speak about one another. Trusted forums, where context is shared, disagreement is protected, and survival pressures can be named honestly alongside the standard. Community is not only where people are praised for doing the right thing. It is also where people can admit that survival is forcing them into choices that the system should not be asking them to make.

Done together, repeated over time, this is what changes the overstory. Not a portal. Not a document. Not a badge. The real product is the environment. An environment in which truthful people are not isolated, reasonable disagreement is protected, practical proof carries social status, farmers set standards from lived reality, industry bodies support without controlling, and divisive voices slowly look socially outdated, because the centre of gravity has moved somewhere else.

The real power is not the record. The real power is the ritual. The point is repeated contact around shared responsibility, until that contact becomes the new overstory.

A movement built on this should not argue with the divisive few. To argue with them is to recognise them. A stronger response is contrast.

While others divide, we build.

While others shout, we verify.

While others blame, we take responsibility.

While others wait to be forced, we act because the industry depends on it.

That is not a message. It is a belonging system.

We are not waiting for institutions to rebuild trust for us. We are rebuilding it between ourselves, through proof, responsibility and shared conduct.

People like us do things like this.

Where this leaves us

If any of this is close to true, the work ahead is not the work the sector usually reaches for. It is not another campaign. It is not another association. It is not another communication strategy. It is the deliberate building of an environment in which responsible people can find one another, set standards from lived reality, hold each other to those standards through proof and peer accountability, and slowly make divisive voices socially smaller without ever once attacking them.

That leaves real questions, not project plans. The questions are the next step, because they are the conversations that have to happen before anything is built.

Who are the trusted few who still carry enough credibility to open this conversation?

What standards would they set for themselves?

What would it look like if industry bodies supported the infrastructure, but farmers held the voice?

Could this be the beginning of a new social contract?

I think it can.

Seamless.S-Elle & Associates
The Fitting

Where you are, where you want to go, and how to get there.

Whatever brought you here, we ask the right questions, find the real answer and recommend where to start.